March 05, 2006

Suffocated

Die-hard advocate of the right to free expression and father of American democracy Thomas Jefferson once said that if he were forced to decide "if we should have a government without newspapers or newspapers without a government, [he] would not hesitate to prefer the latter." The notion of a government's silencing of the press led the drafter of the Declaration of Independence to subsequently declare "I have sworn upon the altar of God, eternal hostility against every form of tyranny over the mind of man."

What compels Carpe Diem Ethiopia to cite a slave-owning Virginian who in 1776 and at 33 years of age breathed words that Ethiopia's rulers can never bring themselves to utter in 2006? Frezer Negash. Her release from jail is cause for all of us to celebrate but this should not obscure the very criminal act of incarcerating her in the first place. We are incensed over Anthony Mitchell's expulsion, the jailing of Ethiopian journalists, and the consequence of these draconian measures to the freedom of thought and expression in Ethiopia.

It is one thing for a government to kick out a foreign journalist on grounds of national security threat. But a decision to render a journalist persona non grata for merely "disseminat[ing] information bent on tarnishing the image of the country" brings us closer to the type of tyranny that made Jefferson lose sleep. And Ethiopians, withered by years of governmental repression understand that ruler tyranny is never a one-time dose; it's part and parcel of an overall intention to muzzle anything printed or spoken by those who disagree. The Walta, ETV, and Fana Radio type of journalism savored by those in power--pamphleteerism--is suffociating and at times puke-worthy. Andrew Heavens' fatigue with what he correctly refers to as blaxploitative headlines is justified (especially those on Gondar) and do nothing to contribute to the marketplace of ideas so stiffled in Ethiopia.

And by the way, what image is Ethiopia upholding? Aren't millions dying of hunger? Didn't you shoot kids in broad daylight? What exactly did Frezer and Anthony say or write that deserved the EPRDF's wrath?

What tarnishes a nation's image are not reports filed by cyber dissenters or foreign correspondents. What does irreparable harm to Ethiopia's image is your brutal quashing of a people's vote; and what makes us shudder is your failure to declare, for example, an immediate end (yes, immediate) to the plight of Ethiopia women who walk around with untreated obstetric fistula. Don't you understand how horrible it is for more than two million Ethiopian women to exist in that condition simply because they have no access to a cheap uncomplicated medical procedure? Don't you folks have mothers, sisters, daughters?

A friend just sent me a copy of a front page news article printed in the Washington Times two weeks ago. The photography and the narrative tell a gut-wrenching Ethiopian story. And while we're at it, the EPRDF should consider filling a federal lawsuit in U.S. district court charging Washington Times reporter Betsy Pisik and the Times of defamation.
Washington Times, A Trail of Tears, March 5, 2006
A humble suggestion to Ethiopia's rulers: how about taking that 7.1 million you all supposedly made selling flowers and ensuring that no Ethiopian will suffer from fitsula in 5 years?
Frezer and child, welcome home.

An Ethiop Office Rant

I have avoided all interaction with the man down the hall in the past several years since I joined this east coast outfit. The dour self-ri...